First, let's get something out of the way: this is not Tini's mac and cheese, and it isn't Toni Chapman's either. There are a lot of amazing baked mac and cheese recipes out there, and those two are well loved for good reason. This one is my own, built from testing and tweaking until it tasted right to me.
How it got here:
My first version, which I posted last year, was a Southern-style baked mac with Gruyère, sharp cheddar, and Monterey Jack. It was creamy and well built, but one thing bothered me: it didn't remind me of Thanksgiving. It leaned sharp and nutty, more "fancy cheese board" than "everybody's at the table." Which again isn’t bad, but just wasn’t what I envisioned. Fabulous recipe, nonetheless.
So I started swapping, and I kept three goals in mind:
Creamy and loose, but not soupy
Mellow, cozy flavor with no sharp bite
A real cheese pull with zero mozzarella
I dropped the Gruyère and sharp cheddar. I landed on medium cheddar, Monterey Jack, and Havarti, plus a little cream cheese in the sauce for silkiness. Medium cheddar keeps the classic flavor without the tang. Havarti is buttery and mild, and it melts loose and creamy. Monterey Jack brings the stretch. Together they gave me exactly what I wanted, and it came out perfect.
So here we are 8 days shy of Thanksgiving with yet another baked mac and cheese recipe on the horizon. It may not be Tini’s or Toni’s, but it is sure to go toe-to-toe with your grandma’s recipe, and is bound to be a delectable side dish for your Thanksgiving menu.
Four-Cheese Baked Mac & Cheese Recipe
Yield: 8-10 servings
Prep: 20 minutes
Cook: 25 minutes
Total: ~45 minutes
Ingredients
Pasta
1 lb elbow macaroni (or cavatappi for the vibes)
Salted water for boiling
Roux
3 tbsp unsalted butter
3 tbsp all-purpose flour
Sauce
1 (12 oz) can evaporated milk
1½ cups whole milk, plus ¼ cup, to loosen sauce, if needed. Warm milk preferably.
2 oz cream cheese, softened and cubed
Cheeses
16 oz medium cheddar (or mild cheddar)
8 oz Monterey Jack
8 oz Havarti
Toss the cheeses together. Use about ¾ (24 oz) in the sauce and save ¼ (8 oz) for layering and topping.
Seasonings
1½ tsp Dijon mustard
½ tsp garlic powder
½ tsp onion powder
¾ tsp salt, or to taste
¼ tsp black pepper
Pinch of nutmeg
Pinch of cayenne
½ tsp smoked paprika, for dusting
Instructions
Cook the pasta. Boil in generously salted water until 3 minutes shy of al dente. Drain, but don't rinse.
Make the roux. Melt the butter in a large saucepan or Dutch oven over medium heat. Whisk in the flour and cook 1-2 minutes until smooth and lightly golden.
Build the sauce. Slowly whisk in the evaporated milk, then the whole milk. Simmer gently 3-4 minutes until slightly thickened. Don't let it boil.
Add the cream cheese. Reduce the heat to low and whisk until fully melted. Make sure cream cheese is softened before adding to ensure it will fully melt and incorporate.
Season. Stir in the Dijon, garlic powder, onion powder, salt, pepper, nutmeg, and cayenne if using. Taste and adjust.
Melt in the cheese. Take the pot off the heat. Add the 24 oz of blended cheese in three or four additions, stirring until smooth after each. If sauce is too thick, temper ¼ cup milk to loosen it.
Combine. Fold in the pasta until every piece is coated.
Assemble. Butter a 9x13-inch baking dish or cast iron skillet. Add half the pasta and sprinkle with half the reserved cheese. Add the remaining pasta, then finish with the rest of the cheese. Dust with smoked paprika.
Bake. 350°F, uncovered, for 15-20 minutes, until bubbly at the edges. Broil 30-60 seconds for a deeper golden top, watching closely.
Rest. Let it sit 10-15 minutes before serving so the sauce settles and holds together.
Notes from Neutral Kitchen 🤎
Shred your own cheese. Pre-shredded cheese has anti-caking agents that can make the sauce grainy.
Add the cheese off the heat. Too much heat makes the fats separate.
Don't overbake. Pull it as soon as it's bubbly. Overbaking is what makes cheese release oil which leads to curdling.
Making it ahead? Assemble without baking and add 5–10 minutes to the bake time from cold.
Want an extra-sturdy sauce? Bump the roux to 4 tbsp butter and 4 tbsp flour. The sturdier base helps the sauce stay creamy through the bake, especially since the pasta keeps absorbing sauce in the oven.



